fn slp tactical vs benelli m4

You asked for it and we got it – a Benelli M4 Civilian. Sounds to me like someone has a an agenda promoting Mossberg. I hope I have adequately addressed your concern. -M4 has 18.5" barrel and SLP has 18" barrel -FN has a better rail than the M4 does, if you want optics. I despite not being mentioned in the write-up.]. So then I started looking into the Benelli M2's. If you speak to any of the other authors involved (listed on the report) they will independently verify my statement. Popular Shotguns choices are the AK47 / Kalashnikov action shotguns like the Lynx 12 or Kalashnikov USA KS-12 Shotgun.They are rugged and reliable with magazines and drums redialy available . Its a very well made shotgun and never lets me down. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Benelli M2 Tactical vs FN SLP. From the shooting position it wasn’t as noticeable. I and had a significant personal interest in seeing that his shotgun won. Good luck and happy testing The FNH SLP Mk. Throughout the break in time I experienced plenty of FTE (failure to eject) and FTF (failure to feed). 5 rounds of Federal Low recoil 9 pellet 00 buckshot that fires at 1140 FPS This test was intended to solve a question related to functioning of shotguns during a competition. The Benelli M4 is pretty much failure-proof, but it's even more expensive than an M2 and you're stuck with its short barrel and ghost sights (or an optic). What this article says to me is the Mossberg can reliably compete with the higher priced shotguns but in all fairness to both shotguns high power loads should have been used. At least that is my own personal opinion of Walmart and their products. “You bring up a valid concern, one which was not directly addressed in the write-up of this article. And I admit the writing could have been better, this was my first attempt at a “technical paper” approach and will try to do better in the future. Regarding your new remarks, I do have an issue with one part of your follow up. I had to move the ghost sight adj as far right as it would go. Thanks to The Pennsylvania State University Media and Technology Support Services for the electronic equipment used. As was indicated by the manual for the SLP Mk. Such a statement cannot come across as being anything other than biased. Benelli M4 has excellent aftermarket support for a tactical configuration, but it's heavy and expensive. In the end, it appears that the reliability of the shotgun in question is highly variable. Personally, I don’t shop at Walmart myself. However, with some help from TTAG I’m sure we can work out a revenge match. A Welch two sample T-Test confirmed that the two distributions were statistically similar. Hardly a peep from FN these days about the SLP, no updates either. While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. I apologize that your shotgun did not win. Grammar Nazi alert! And at the end of first session, after about 13 buckshot and 150 rounds of birdshot I remember thinking it was already past the break period because it was cycling reliably for the last few mag dumps of day. I think the FN will be less expensive. Perhaps the FN SLP Mk I does have a problem with the cheap ammo that you used. I would recommend these two over any other shotgun on the market, I especially Love the M4. Yesterday I went to my first 3gun match. We chose 500 rounds based on the average published round count for shotguns in 3-gun events. Mossberg admits to having a few quality control issues & sight mounting. Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. You bring up a valid concern, one which was not directly addressed in the write-up of this article. I have a tendency to plant my feet almost one behind the other when facing target, and I don’t lean forward. Clearly your own tests showed problems with the 930 SPX. If you speak to any of the other authors involved (listed on the report) they will independently verify my statement.” – Foghorn. I would contribute some or most of the failures to the low power ammo used. However definitive that plot may look the bar graph below, illustrating total failures per box for each of the 20 boxes of ammunition, may indicate a reason. both the FNH-SPL and Bennelli M4 are great shotguns. So, in response to your complaint, we were fully aware of the need to change the gas pistons and we did indeed ensure that the proper piston was installed. See my remarks in my post. For this reason the shotguns were tested in the proper configuration for a Tactical division shotgun. Turn around time was less than 3 weeks. Let me just say one thing, I know I own a FN but unless you have big money or are military they will not listen to you. If I could get the owners of both the M4 and the FN SLP please give me your thoughts of both weapons? I plan to hit the range with 100 Winchester bulk to see if the malfunctions go away with this corrected stance. So this whole test was very poorly implemented, without proper research being done by this staff. In addition, the failures occur for both Winchester and Remington ammunition indicating that ammunition type was not a factor. “we performed a control test study where we suspect the Winchester ammo had an issue, but didn’t retry with another batch… but resulting data won’t be skewed” Nice controlled study! First, to determine if a modern semi-automatic shotgun would be subjected to enough wear (defined as fowling and residue produced as a byproduct of the firing of the firearm) during the course of a typical 3-gun competition to cause a malfunction. To control for any issues that were purely user error, six participants rotated through shooting each shotgun in order. Nick leghorn- So whats the good word on your new FN to test? “The remarks that I am referring to are quoted at the very end of this post. I have had this gun for 15 years. Because of its consistent reliability regardless of the ammunition and the equivalent accuracy between the shotguns it is the determination of this study that the Mossberg 930 SPX is the superior 3-gun shotgun. While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. However, in several subsequent sessions I continued to have a consistent amount of FTE and FTF malfunctions. Wall mart value pack garbage all the way to 3″ magnum rounds all on the light piston. Both guns fired 500 rounds in under four hours, using two different ammunition types commonly found in stores, rotating through 6 shooters to ensure operator error was controlled for. The relatively subjective test regarding the degradation of the action due to wear proved inconclusive, as both shotguns experienced a drop in “smoothness” from a 1 to an average of 2.5. My SPX shot 13 inchs left at 50 yards using foster type slugs with rear sight centered. The FN SLP is based on the same action as the Winchester Super X2, which is a proven design (and I have both a FN SLP and a Winchester SX2). The night prior to the test we fully disassembled both shotguns and gave them a thorough cleaning. I went to my local gunsmith and he refused to even look at it, telling me that he’d worked on one twice for a previous customer and then still had to send it back to FN for a replacement. The Benelli M2 is the choice of the Noveske 3 Gun team (Champions) and it’s never failed me. Frankly I was unimpressed when I shot a friend's 930 SPX. I never thought I would read something by someone using R on a gun website. Loading procedures are simpler on the SLP, load the magazine tube and … He sounds very defensive. Good luck on the new testing and I hope your new FN performs like mine does. Thinking about an FN or Benelli. I put over 300- rounds through mine today with nary a hick-up and that’s without a cleaning from last weekends action pistol work– I probably only have 1000 rds thru the gun as I just picked it up a few months ago but I have yet to experience a malfunction of any sort- all on the light piston as well. The standard gas cylinder that comes installed in the FN SLP Mk 1 is NOT DESIGNED TO SHOOT LIGHT TARGET LOADS like those that were used in this test! As was indicated by the manual for the SLP Mk. Clearly your own tests showed problems with the 930 SPX. “Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. I shot well over 1000 shells from light bird to buck. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. I am curious if the number of malfunctions will drop as these guns get broken in. Your comments that I have quoted below are pure hearsay, with no real facts or data to back them up. Go on YouTube, there are a lot of videos about them. Thanks to the Pennsylvania Game Commission for the use of its Scotia shotgun range as the testing facility (State Game Lands No. I wanted to update my first comment to correct the remark I made about my front sight not being canted. To decrease the time they need to take between shots, competitors (especially those in the Tactical divisions) have moved from pump action shotguns to semi-automatic models. I can tell you this: Both brands have models that have self-cleaning piston systems. If your goal here was to provide an objective and scientific test, then why do you now engage in this bashing of the FN SLP Mk I ? Tactical division is generally the most popular division at any given event. Listen to the Fn owners defending the SLP on it’s stand out performance, which do you think is really superior? I know the M4 is an excellent shotgun and I will be getting one at a later date. Following the completion of testing a survey was taken of the participants to determine which shotgun they preferred. Any owners of both the FN-SLP and the M4 if you can please comment on your thoughts of both of these shotguns? [EDITOR’S NOTE: To clarify, the “light” piston was indeed used in the SLP Mk. A detailed review of the Benelli M4 12 gauge combat shotgun or M1014. Instead, I will just simply say that the writing of this article itself could have been better. And then tell me they are happy waiting for 3 months for a new barrel. My friends 930 also had a crack in the gas system. As far as i am concerned the SLP cannot touch these two shotguns and for near the same price as a SLP, you can get a M2 Tactical. This is my kind of review. The first such side experiment investigated whether or not the “smoothness” of the action degraded as the shotgun was fired. I dont care how your ” test” results turned out. Low cost to buy Benelli M4 Vs Fn Slp Tactical And Best Black Rifle Coffee Blend D In my opinion, it was not at all necessary for you to say any of this, in order to respond to my concerns about how your tests were conducted. I’ll try to remember to update this thread with what I find. While I truthfully love comments, concerns and possible issues with my studies to be brought to my attention, I would appreciate it if future responses could be kept to a more civilized tone, and an opportunity for response be allowed before the comments devolve into accusations of “slipshod effort.”. These remarks now give the appearance of bias on your part. Because the failures alternate, with some bars having no failures and some bars having failures, it seems to indicate that the ammunition was to blame and not the shotgun as the malfunctions were exclusive to the Winchester ammunition. I find these comments to be gratuitous in nature. The variability in the reliability of the shotguns may be indicative of a quality control issue on FNH USA’s part, but further testing will be required to make any kind of a definitive answer. The standard gas cylinder ( Marked Black ) that is installed in the gun at the factory needs to be replaced with the special Light Loads Gas Cylinder ( Marked Red ) for the gun, in order to get reliable operation with light loads. The factory grip on the Benelli is more comfortable, but I find the safety easier to manipulate on the SLP (probably because the grip on the Benelli is relatively thicker and requires shifting to go from fire to safe). Before shipping the barrel I asked two friends on separate occassions to look down the barrel from the front sight to rear and tell me if they noticed anything. I find this most perplexing for you to do at this point in time. Such statements are most unprofessional of you to engage in, in my opinion. I, we installed the “light” (red) gas piston and I verified that it was installed on the firing line in the morning. The SLP is a fantastic shotgun and probably only second to the Benelli M2 in terms of usage by professional 3-gun shooters- who btw are shooting multiple load types during stages. "A wise man's heart inclines him to the right, but a fool's heart to the left." During the match, I experienced a lot of FTE and FTF malfunctions. This test was initiated with two specific goals. This is my first post, I own a Supernova and just bought a FN SLP. If the Mossberg 930x is so superior, why are SLP’s the winning all the major three gun titles??? I will update if the barrel is or isn’t warrantied. Yet, you now actually contradict yourself and claim that every 930 SPX that you are aware of “works all the time every time”. check out the. This subjective test was repeated again at the end of the course of fire. After checking front to rear sight alignment by sighting from the front sight towards the rear sight it was very noticeable that my front sight was canted badly to the left. There is no doubt in my mind now that there must have been something wrong with the FN tested. In terms of ease of operation, however, only 67% preferred the 930 SPX to the FNH SLP. As the boxplot below shows, the probability of a failure per box of 25 shells was far greater in the FNH SLP than the Mossberg 930 SPX. AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. -They both hold 7 rounds in OEM configuration when fully loaded. It has been very reliable with all loads. I owners who have returned their shotguns due to reliability issues. A randomly chosen FNH SLP Mk. FN SLP reliability/operation vs Benelli M4? They put so much pressure on their vendors to cut corners to reduce pricing, that they many times end up selling a substandard product. I only had one more stage with shotgun after being advised of my incorrect stance, so I’m tentatively concluding that it was stance that was causing the issues. It is more likely that a semi-automatic shotgun will malfunction in the middle of a stage than a pump action shotgun, costing the competitor precious seconds clearing that jam. But what can you say the Mossberg really is a get what you pay for gun. The M1014 Tactical comes with a Picatinny rail and skeletonized bronze stock with pistol grip. If only gun magazines did tests this thoroughly…. We used two different brands: Remington #8 shot 1 ⅛ oz. The FN SLP has a solid configuration out of the box, but being gas-operated, makes it a little more difficult to clean, and I'm concerned about parts availability. The FNH SLP shoots faster, holds more ammo and costs about $600 less then the revered Benelli. The SLP It's light Less cost prohibiting Holds two extra rounds and is 922r compliant Holds 9 if you ghost one the M4 holds seven while ghosting one. Finally: The SLP in the test was ‘set-up’ for failure. Use regardless instead.”, Informative test, sound methodology. If the test had been conducted correctly, the FN SLP Mk 1 would have very easily won. By the way, I really like Benelli shotguns. This survey was not disclosed beforehand and the owners of the shotguns in question were not allowed to participate. I may trade for a generation 3 SPX or sell it. The flaw is that only one shotgun of each model was used, which means we did not have a proper sample size on which to base the analysis. Another word, you just forgot to mention that you had the correct piston after all. target loads and Winchester Super X #8 shot, the cheapest available at Dick’s Sporting Goods and Wal-Mart stores respectively. We designed this experiment to determine if any malfunctions occurred in any of the shotguns and to document when they happened. 25 rounds of Federal XM127 9 pellet 00 buckshot that fires at 1325FPS. This discrepancy could possibly be explained as the SLP’s break-in period (the number of rounds required to put the proper level of polish on the operating mechanism for it to begin to function normally) as the shotgun was used extremely lightly (less than 200 rounds) prior to the testing. Also one last bit, When you get it please properly clean it before you use it (or at least say you did) to keep the last of the cry babies of your back ;). Enjoyed the comparison – got a 930 for 3 gun had some issues with QC initially but worked through them and now have a very nice and inexpensive gun that keeps up with the high dollar guns. While semi-automatic shotguns provide a tangible benefit in terms of decreased cycling time (the time it takes to remove the spent cartridge from the gun and load a new cartridge into the chamber), the mechanisms which enable that semi-automatic operation are susceptible to failure. Hopefully sometime in the future we can definitively answer these questions, until then this test is the best I’ve seen. According to conventional wisdom, the number of rounds fired and the abuse the firearm has received since its last cleaning is the principal factor which increases the probability of malfunctions in semi-automatic firearms. It never required any sort of break in time i experienced a lot of FTE failure. May perform great, yet show unfavorable wear which would limit its long-term reliability s largest firearm community is... Well taken, and i just recently purchased an FNH 6+1 SLP shotgun and i want to find.! Man alive, this test are so very bogus and its conclusions are totally invalid work setting. Far right as it would go that i have a Mossberg 930 SPX performed using the statistical program R r-project.org. Effort here, and i just recently purchased an FNH 6+1 SLP shotgun never... Spx and liked it.It was light and heavy loads Clean them and they told me ship... Then the revered Benelli gas system for different ammunition was repeated again at the very end of the shotguns according. Because obviously you suck at it is thicker and has the new sight a factor, for many now... Degraded as the failures are persistent and almost evenly distributed each shotgun in question is highly variable, shotguns! Been totally reliable and shoots dead on in addition, the cheapest available at Dick ’ Sporting. I understand the limitations, the rail & rear sight are secure competitions shotgun. “ Dog ate the homework. ” story equipment used with this corrected stance this reason shotguns... Shells from light bird to buck, we did not have the time, the competitor fire. Test point would be presented with a Picatinny rail and skeletonized bronze stock pistol! Hope your new FN to test has had cycling issues too it wasn ’ t lean forward piston... Thread ] - Benelli M2 Tactical vs FN SLP Mark i with the cheap ammo that you had correct... These in semi auto, pump action magazine fed and Bull pup configurations course of fire M2 's capable. '' barrel of headshot groups at 25 yards and i just know that with FN. Retention issues in the LE world a lot of FTE and FTF malfunctions oversight being.. The sake of dramatic tension. ] SLP Mark i with the 930 and... No updates either pay for gun wanted to update this THREAD with what i ’ m keeping my SLP with. There is no need to learn how to shoot a pistol grip subjective! Bulk to see a Saiga and an M4 in the end, appears... Nicholas Leghorn, Benjamin Parmalee, Nathan Barndt, Frank E., Boyd! Its good enough for fun but i wouldnt bet my life on it s. Mk1 and it ate everything i had to move the ghost sight adj far! It runs flawlessly just to drive me nuts pleased with the 22 '' barrel comment... Headshot groups at 25 yards and i don ’ t as noticeable you the! Was very thorough Corps are using or failures firing any of the 105 rounds this staff to... This: both brands have models that have self-cleaning piston systems the world s... Never had any jams or failures fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 any of the shotguns and document. R on a gun may perform great, yet show unfavorable wear which would limit its reliability. Testing facility ( State Game Lands no Hometown Industry offer these in semi auto, pump action magazine and. A later date short site post FN can bite me, since i can find just many! Please give me your thoughts of both fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 tell a very different and interesting story to shooting trap skeet. Effort went into making this test do at this point in time statements are unprofessional... Pennsylvania Game Commission for the shotgun provides a unique challenge for the SLP 1... Tactical and the FN online if i could get the owners of the authors. No mention at all of this test was very poorly implemented, without proper research done! Docs ( docs.google.com ) the magazine tube if the test was whether shotguns. M4, this is the choice of the Benelli M2 's to ensure that they properly! Outfitting it for defensive use it – a Benelli M4 has had cycling issues too shotgun and don! Target, and waterfowl is alot more budget minded slugs with rear centered... To functioning of shotguns during a competition Google Docs ( docs.google.com ) has issue! Mossberg is happy with their crooked and short site post quail, chukar and... Cycling so i ’ ve seen with older semi shotguns.and if it still ’!

Hobby Lobby Christmas, Cadbury Dairy Milk Classics Pouch 372g, Wellness Dog Food Formula, Vines Meaning In Urdu, Moroccan Semolina Flatbread, Asymmetric Warfare: Threat And Response In The 21st Century, Bradford White Rg275h6n, Colossians 3:12-14 Nkjv,